Brett Starling, a junior kicker from Hampton University, has been placed on the 2026 Fred Mitchell Award Watch List, recognizing him as one of the top kickers across FCS, Division II, III, NAIA, and NJCAA football. He is among only 39 selected kickers, with only three representing the Coastal Athletic Association. Starling achieved significant success in the 2025 season, making 11 of 12 field goals and executing all 26 extra points. His accomplishments have garnered him third team All-CAA and 2026 first-team preseason All-CAA honors.

By the Numbers
  • 11 of 12 field goals made in 2025.
  • 26 successful extra point conversions in 2025.
  • 42.3-yard average per punt on 65 attempts.
  • 10 punts within the 20-yard line and 12 over 50 yards.
State of Play
  • Starling is one of three Coastal Athletic Association kickers on the watch list.
  • He is among four kickers from HBCU institutions recognized.
  • The Fred Mitchell Award honors outstanding kickers based on performance on the field and community involvement.
What's Next

As the season progresses, Starling's performance will be critical in determining his eligibility for the Fred Mitchell Award, alongside continuing to showcase his skills in punting and field goal attempts. His standing among his peers will significantly impact future selections.

Bottom Line

Brett Starling鈥檚 recognition on the Fred Mitchell Award Watch List highlights his impressive all-around kicking abilities and sets high expectations for his upcoming season, placing him among the elite in college football kicking performance.