Evan Dempsey has been named a Unanimous All-American by D1Baseball.com, joining the ranks of only one other player in Florida Gulf Coast University (FGCU) history, Chris Sale. Dempsey, a standout two-way player, earned first-team honors from all required publications, solidifying his status in collegiate baseball. In addition to his All-American recognition, he received accolades as the Atlantic Sun Conference Pitcher of the Year and first-team all-conference honors for both pitching and hitting. Dempsey's impressive 2026 season included a .333 batting average, 10 home runs, and a stellar 7-2 record with a 3.15 ERA on the mound. Dempsey's achievements underscore his dual-threat ability, making him a key figure in FGCU's baseball milestones.

By the Numbers
  • Dempsey achieved a .333 batting average with 79 hits, including 10 home runs and 46 RBI.
  • On the mound, he posted a 7-2 record, a 3.15 ERA, and led the league with 126 strikeouts.
State of Play
  • Dempsey is the second player in FGCU history to earn the Unanimous All-American title, the first being Chris Sale in 2010.
  • No other player from the Atlantic Sun Conference received All-American recognition this year.
What's Next

As Dempsey continues his college career, there may be increased attention from Major League Baseball scouts, considering his outstanding dual-threat performance. Future accolades could include potential nominations for additional prestigious awards as he continues to develop his skills.

Bottom Line

Evan Dempsey's Unanimous All-American title reinforces his status as one of the elite players in collegiate baseball, highlighting FGCU's growing prominence in the sport. His remarkable talent as both a pitcher and position player positions him as a potential future star in professional baseball.