The Pittsburgh Steelers underwent a significant transformation this offseason, highlighted by Mike Tomlin's resignation and the hiring of Mike McCarthy. The team added over 30 new players, including key free agents like Rico Dowdle and Jamel Dean, while also making a strategic trade for Michael Pittman Jr. Analysts Sam Monson and Steve Palazzolo expressed mixed feelings about these moves, particularly regarding the re-signing of 42-year-old quarterback Aaron Rodgers. Despite concerns over Rodgers' age, there is optimism surrounding improved performance from both the offense and defense.

By the Numbers
  • Over 30 new players added to the Steelers' roster.
  • 10 players selected in the 2026 draft to bolster depth.
Yes, But

Despite the positive additions, there is skepticism about the decision to bring back Aaron Rodgers, with some arguing that a younger quarterback like Malik Willis could have provided a better long-term solution. Monson believes the difference in offseason grades hinges on Rodgers' potential impact.

State of Play
  • Mike McCarthy's coaching staff is seen as a strong advantage for the Steelers.
  • Defensive talent remains high, potentially leading to improved consistency.
What's Next

The Steelers will be closely watched in the upcoming season to see if their offseason changes yield success on the field, particularly how Rodgers performs with a revamped offense and if young quarterbacks can develop behind him.

Bottom Line

While the Steelers made notable additions this offseason, the overarching question remains their choice to stick with Rodgers, suggesting an urgent need for immediate success rather than long-term planning. Their future hinges on his performance and the overall impact of a reshaped roster.