Paige McMenemy has resigned as Head Softball Coach at Tiffin University to assume the Head Coach position at Ohio University. Over five years, she led the Dragons to a record of 152-108, including significant NCAA postseason appearances and multiple conference championships. Her tenure included back-to-back G-MAC regular season titles and being named G-MAC Coach of the Year in 2025 and 2026. Under her guidance, Tiffin's program saw steady improvement, culminating in a peak season of 43-14 in 2025. Athletic Director Kelly Daniel expressed gratitude for McMenemy鈥檚 leadership, which has profoundly impacted the program and its athletes.

By the Numbers
  • McMenemy's overall coaching record: 152-108 (.585)
  • Conference record: 79-41 (.658)
  • Peak season: 43-14 in 2025
  • G-MAC play record over last two seasons: 41-7
State of Play
  • Tiffin University's softball team improved from 22-28 in McMenemy's first season to a peak of 43-14.
  • The team achieved back-to-back NCAA regional appearances and G-MAC championships during her tenure.
What's Next

McMenemy will transition to Ohio University as Head Coach, where she aims to replicate her success and further develop the program. Tiffin University will now search for a new head coach to build on the momentum she created.

Bottom Line

McMenemy鈥檚 departure marks a significant turning point for Tiffin University's softball program, emphasizing her impactful leadership and the challenges ahead as the institution seeks a successor to continue the program's upward trajectory.