Evan Dempsey of Florida Gulf Coast University has received two more First Team All-America honors from Baseball America and Perfect Game, bringing his total to seven All-America accolades. With this recognition, he is one acknowledgment shy of achieving Consensus All-American status, having previously become FGCU's first Consensus All-American last year. Dempsey's impressive 2026 season included being named the Atlantic Sun Conference's Pitcher of the Year, and he earned accolades as both a pitcher and an outfielder. His standout statistics and dual-role performance underscore his significant impact on the diamond this year.

By the Numbers
  • Dempsey recorded a .333 batting average with 79 hits, including 10 home runs and 15 stolen bases.
  • On the mound, he holds a 7-2 record with a 3.15 ERA and a league-leading 126 strikeouts in 15 starts.
State of Play
  • Dempsey is currently a finalist for multiple prestigious awards, including the Dick Howser Trophy and the Golden Spikes Award.
  • This marks the first time in FGCU history that a player has earned back-to-back All-America honors.
What's Next

Dempsey seeks to solidify his Consensus All-American designation by securing one more First Team nod from a remaining publication. His outstanding performance in both batting and pitching roles could elevate him further in the 2026 MLB Draft discussions. Fans and the FGCU community are expected to rally behind him as opportunities develop in the championship postseason.

Bottom Line

Evan Dempsey鈥檚 dual-threat capabilities make him a standout athlete in college baseball, and his pursuit of Consensus All-American status could pave the way for a bright future, potentially at the professional level. He embodies the excellence of FGCU athletics and sets a benchmark for aspirational players.